Friday, February 20, 2015

So what is Compassion?

Rippling water of river Ganges--grey and alive

[Today, Feb 20, 2015 across the world #1000Speak for Compassion. This post is one of those voices. Please find other posts here: http://1000speak.wordpress.com/ or on twitter with hashtag #1000Speak . You can also learn more about his project on this youtube video]

Kindness is giving to another. For example, when you give your old clothes away to the needy or food to the hungry. There is a clear sense of the Other, someone who is not you to whom you are giving. At the end of it, you may feel good about yourself, happy, pleased at having spent a day responsibly.

Compassion is when your sense of the Other slips away, when you become deeply self-identified with the pain and needs of the Other, when their needs become yours. That is stage-I of compassion. Some examples:

My favorite Chicana writer and feminist Gloria E. AnzaldĂșa writes in one of her books that she once saw a blade of grass being burnt by a still-smouldering cigarette stub. Soon she could feel the pain of the grass in her, as if it is was her own skin being scorched.

My mother came panting towards me. I looked up to find her face flushed, breathing heavily and in tears: “Oh! They are cutting down the neem tree, they are cutting down the neem tree. Do something.” Saying thus she turned, stumbled back onto the terrace—to sob, to rant, to swear, to plead to her neighbours: “Understand how wonderful this tree is. She has asked nothing from you but look how much she gives. Shade, medicine, even her presence is good for all of you...don’t cut her, please don’t cut her.” I watch the Wild Mother flailing her arms, her skin loose, her voice trembling and wonder if that tree is her child who is to be executed. [No, the tree was not executed. She still lives gloriously next to my mom. The other day mom handed over some neem leaves to treat for swine flu.]

I entered the cowshed and found the farm hand on the floor, amidst cow urine and dung, sobbing loudly. The sick cow lay on the floor, her body stretched and face contorted in obvious pain. The farm hand is a middle-aged lady, so thin that it appears as if her skin drapes her bones. She earns Rs 1000/- month (about $16/month). She is not married. I do not know if she was ever married. But I know she has a brother who comes every now and then to get her to sign some government documents for money. She probably owns 3-4 saris. She works during the day- cleaning the institute and the cowshed, milking the many cows, taking them to graze and watching over visitor needs. Today one of the cows has fallen sick. The man appointed to take care of them at night was careless and something happened. She is sobbing on the floor as if she has been injured herself: “How could he be this careless? How could he? Where is the vet? Why has he not come in as yet? All these vets are useless.” Tears continuously well up her eyes and flow down like a deluge. Her thin body wracks in spasms. I look at the cow—in her pain, does she feel witnessed?

The couple tell me about the day they delivered their son. Of her excruciating pain and that moment when she was given epidural injection and asked to sit still for sometime and how pain came in one unbearable wave after another. That she held his hands, pressed her pain into his palms and that when she looked up, she saw her pain in his eyes. Now with a serene baby boy she tells me—we have been through much together but culmination of that journey was that day. I don’t remember my pain anymore, he remembers. But I remember how he looked, that he cried more than I did. What can be more validating than to see my pain in his eyes!

I tell myself—I will mute notifications to his facebook posts. Everyday I hear his wall asking, reminding, pushing, cajoling, pleading for those we don’t see or care for in our everyday lives. Everyday without fail a post bristles asking me to do something. No, he is not working with an NGO. He has a fulltime job and a family. And all the responsibilities that come with it. But every spare moment is given to the larger family of humanity. For some months now he has taken up the issue of farmer suicides to heart. He devices multiple ways to get people to pay more attention and give before one more farmer dies. He fasts on Tuesdays for them. He has invented an Indian Farmer’s League to get more people involved. Sometimes when I read his posts I wonder if they are his kith and kin, his own lost some generations back to the rural-urban divide. But he has no time to ruminate on these things. He is out there in whatever online space he can find, doing whatever he can—inform, awaken, plead, interest, cajole, push, demand—relentlessly, day after day after day. Here is his blogpost on farmer suicides "Why the need to play Indian Farmer's League" Here is his online fundraiser "Help Vidarbha Farmers". This amongst many.

Stage-I compassion is when you identify deeply with another’s pain till it becomes yours. Stage-II compassion is when you help that pain as you would help yourself—immediately, desperately, smartly, effectively, strategically, without feeling inconvenienced, and relentlessly.

There are further stages to compassion, stages that finally lead us to the state of the river—to flow effortlessly, give easily, inclusively and always.

36 comments:

  1. Compassion is when your sense of the other slips away - I love that. So well said.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for sharing your stories of compassion. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lovely examples. Especially the one of your Mom and the Neem tree. If only we all realize the importance, the world will so much more beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your stories brought tears to my eyes. It is truly wonderful how some people can truly feel and do for others! Including you!! :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I am sure you must have had tears in your eyes while writing this post at some point and that alone validates your conviction to what you wrote. Your actions, words and posts touch me so much that that I long to become like a river. Hugs and thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Lovely post..best is if we fail the pain and take action to ease the pain.. The farmers surely need help.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your stories are truly poignant, expressing what compassion truly is. Beautiful post for 1000 voices.

    ReplyDelete
  8. More people need to read this... then they will understand what the whole concept of compassion is really about. awesome post

    ReplyDelete
  9. What a moving and incredibly powerful post! So so glad I came here through #1000Speak. I admire the way you distinguished between Stage 1 and stage 2 Compassion. The person you speak of is a true son of the soil where the pain of others becomes his own pain. How absolutely commendable and humbling.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Beautiful stories. I loved the one about the neem tree the most.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Beautiful post...
    You have given good examples...
    Also you have explained it very well.
    Compassion is needed.
    Thanks for writing about this.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The way your words weave the stories of compassion tells a lot about how committed and passionate you are towards everything that goes around you.

    Thank you for the wonderful words

    ReplyDelete
  13. I don't have words to express . Could feel it instead. Thanks :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. I was so waiting to read your post particularly for I know you are one person who is filled with compassion and how much of it you carry for this world. Those are beautiful, touching stories. No wonder your mom cried for the Neem tree. As mom, as daughter. :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. you humble me, bhavana...such deep understanding and knowledge, wrapped up in such love and action....

    ReplyDelete
  16. Beautifully expressed!
    Stages of compassion is so right.
    Compassion needs action too.
    May we have more people like your friend, who take action & keep on informing and motivating others to take action.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I hear you" "Compassion needs action too."

    ReplyDelete
  18. My dear young man--seeing your comment on my blog was the best gift for writing this article. Thank you so much!

    ReplyDelete
  19. We learnt how to understand together, no?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hahaha. Thank you. We mirror each other, no?

    ReplyDelete
  21. Suri, people like you inspire to write. Thank you for the work you do.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thank you Lancelot. In the huge deluge of compassion on the internet, this a drop.

    ReplyDelete
  23. :) Yes, that day was special the way my mother ranted against her neighbors. I never thought ranting could be useful:P

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks Shailaja for being here. Yes, for all the pain in the world there are some wonderful people too. In fact I think most of us are wonderful in moments. If we could only drag those moments, stretch it a bit longer...

    ReplyDelete
  25. Thanks Roshan. Your post was inspirational. Glad to be part of this journey.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Thank you. Wasn't the entire #1000Speak drive a powerful force for us to see the good and the willing?

    ReplyDelete
  27. Yes, don't they? And yet what actions do we take. As long as we have food in the table how do we care where it came from and what happened there?

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks. I had tears when I had witnessed many of these events. Writing was sharing those beautiful moments.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Including you! Gentle and consistent. Thanks for bringing all of us to #1000Speak. It was a satisfying week.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Yeah. I wish, I wish.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Thank you for being here :)

    ReplyDelete
  32. You got the core. Gracias for reaching to it.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking the time to read through this post. Would love to hear back from you:):)